Encyclopedia of the Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy (
2023)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
Special obligations toward compatriots are more controversial than other forms of partiality, because compatriot relationships are relatively “impersonal.” Even so, a variety of justifications for special duties among compatriots have been defended. This entry outlines three such accounts, drawing on categories identified in previous literature (Tan 2003, 2004; Beaton et al. 2021). The first two approaches – the instrumental approach and the institutional approach – derive special obligations to compatriots from general duties of justice. By contrast, the third approach is relational in nature and grounds the justification for compatriot partiality directly in the special relationship compatriots share.