Engineering Genders: Pluralism, Trans Identities, and Feminist Philosophy
Dissertation, University of Sheffield (
2020)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
This thesis is an attempt to provide an account of gender. In particular, it is an attempt to develop
an ameliorative approach to gender that satisfies a number of transfeminist political goals. That is,
following Sally Haslanger, I ask what do we want gender to be? In order to answer the question, I
develop a novel Neurathian methodology for conceptual engineering, and a distinctively ‘activist’
take on that project. From there I criticise a number of theories of gender and suggest that we
should instead adopt a position I call Ameliorative Semantic Pluralism. That is, a position that endorses
multiple meanings for gender terms. I develop this position in conversation with those traditions
that arose from the anti-essentialism debates of the 1990s – family resemblance theories, Butlerian
performativity, deflationism, scepticism, and nihilism about gender. I provide novel critiques of
each position but take seriously the concerns that each position had. I end the thesis by drawing
on Audre Lorde to engineer one of the senses of the term ‘agender’ that speaks to my
phenomenology, before using that account to critique some further recent attempts to theorise
nonbinary gender identities.